Skip to content
Cedar Crest College How To Apply
Menu
On this page

Search marketing

Black Hat Backlinks: The Problems and Techniques to Avoid

A vendor sends you a spreadsheet of publishers and promises followed links. Open one of the sample articles. Read the paragraph around the link, check where it goes, and ask who approved it. Those checks can tell you more about the proposal than the domain scores in the spreadsheet.

A proposal and two printed publisher pages beside a magnifying glass and review tabs.
Read a sample placement in context and compare it with the seller’s written terms.

How black hat backlinks can hurt a site

A backlink is a link to one of your pages from another site. A trade publication might link to a checklist because readers can use it to complete a task. Black hat backlinks are links acquired mainly to manipulate search rankings. Google calls this link spam. Start by looking at the page and the reason for the link, as you would with ordinary backlink examples.

Google’s systems can discount spammy links. If a site had benefited from them, that benefit can disappear when the links are neutralized. A human reviewer can also issue a manual action that affects how some or all of a site appears in Search. The automation and the manual review have different evidence. Google describes the loss of ranking benefit in its spam updates guidance.

There are costs before any search change appears. A campaign can spend money on pages that relevant readers seldom see. A link can disappear when a publisher changes ownership or removes the placement. If the purchase terms and source URLs were never recorded, it can take time to work out which links the business can ask to have removed.

Link-building techniques to avoid

Review the reason for the link, the relationship between the parties, and the way the placement is produced. The examples below cover common patterns in Google’s link spam policies.

Patterns to look for in a placement
TechniqueWhat to check
Paid links that pass ranking creditCheck whether money, a product, or a service is exchanged for a link. Review the agreement and how the publisher marks the link in the live page.
Private blog networksLook for a group of sites controlled by the same operator and used mainly to place ranking links. Read the sites’ recent coverage and ask who makes editorial decisions.
Scaled guest posts and insertionsCheck for repeated commercial anchors, similar paragraphs on unrelated sites, and edits to old articles that add little information for the reader.
Excessive link exchangesLook for reciprocal links required by the arrangement, especially blocks of partner links created solely to trade placement.
Automated and sitewide linksCheck whether the same link is generated across comment threads, low-value directories, widgets or footer templates with little reason for a visitor to use it.
Unauthorized insertionsAsk who approved the edit. An unexpected commercial link on an unrelated page warrants a check with the publisher or the owner of the affected site.

Check a pattern before drawing a conclusion. Several publishers can share a theme or a hosting provider. Read a few pages from each publication and look at the bylines, topics, link destinations and ownership information available to you. A group of unrelated articles carrying the same sales anchors and tied to the same purchase record gives you a stronger reason to investigate.

Look at the specific section where the seller proposes to publish. A well-known host can have areas with different audiences, access and editorial processes. Ask who commissioned the article and why that audience would seek it out. Google’s site reputation abuse policy addresses third-party pages published mainly to benefit from the host’s established ranking signals. Read the examples of site reputation abuse.

Check the history of a domain if a seller emphasizes rankings or links from the site’s earlier years. Compare the topics in older public snapshots with the material readers see today. An expired domain repurposed mainly to influence rankings with pages of little value warrants the same scrutiny as the placement itself. Ask for a reason the current publication serves the audience you need.

Check the terms of a sponsored article

A sponsored article can be purchased for exposure to a relevant audience. Agree on the deliverable and reader disclosure with the publisher. Google prefers rel="sponsored" for paid links and accepts rel="nofollow" as well. Check the live anchor against Google’s outbound link guidance.

Review how a reader will recognize the article as advertising when its format resembles the publication’s editorial work. Keep the disclosure clear and close to the content it describes. The FTC covers these decisions in its guide to native advertising.

If a reviewer receives a product or another benefit, check whether the arrangement creates a material connection that readers should know about. The FTC gives practical examples in its endorsement disclosure guidance.

Ask for evidence before approving a proposal

Ask for a representative live placement and the terms under which it was acquired. A vendor offering backlinks should be able to identify the publication, explain the reader benefit, and describe the publisher’s approval process. Review the details before authorizing spend.

Questions for the seller

  • Which page will carry the link? Ask for a live example and confirm that it is in the part of the site your audience actually uses.
  • Who controls the copy? Ask who can accept, edit or decline an article or link and who will maintain it later.
  • What does the fee cover? Ask for separate terms for writing, placement and promotion. Ask how the publisher will disclose payment and qualify the link.
  • What happens when the page changes? Ask for the publication URL and a record of the destination, anchor, link attribute and any replacement terms.

Compare quotations against the work they include. Check the publication’s fit, editorial involvement and expected exposure, then decide what you can verify after publication. Use those details when deciding how to evaluate guest post prices.

Inspect the sample in a browser. Follow the link to confirm where it ends up and use the browser’s element inspector to check the anchor’s rel value. Record the stated and observed destination if a redirect is involved. For paid promotion, confirm the disclosure is visible to a reader and the live link matches the publisher’s agreement.

Domain Authority (DA) and Page Authority (PA) can help organize a shortlist. If they appear in a quote, verify the proposed page and its recent editorial activity alongside the figures. Review how to check DA and PA.

Record the tool and date if you include an authority estimate. Google explains what outside services can observe and how to evaluate predictions in its guidance on third-party SEO tools.

Read the proposed link sentence aloud. Ask whether the words help someone predict what they will find at the destination. Where the same commercial phrase is required across unrelated articles, ask the publisher to choose wording that fits each page. Use natural anchor text that serves the reader.

Trace existing links to the records you have

Start with the source pages you can inspect and the placements you can trace to an invoice, order sheet or outreach email. Export a sample of discovered links from Search Console. The report gives you a starting set to investigate and can include links Google found over time. See the Search Console Links report.

A laptop, an invoice and handwritten-style audit notes on a worktable.
Match the observed source page and destination to any acquisition record you have.

Collect the source URLs from the export, order sheet and outreach records. A URL list extractor can pull URLs out of supplied text so you can organize the review. Keep the original records and the exact linking page as well as the domain. One domain can contain many different pages.

For each checked placement, record the source page, destination, visible anchor, link attribute and date observed. Save the surrounding text and any purchase or publisher correspondence. If you encounter a blocked or unavailable source, record that status and keep the decision open until you have enough evidence. Use the observed link and the arrangement behind it when deciding what requires action.

Keep individual pages visible when you group results. A report might show many links from a single domain because the same footer appears throughout the site. Trace a sample back to the shared template before opening a long list of separate requests. For a link found on several copies of an article, record which publisher and which copies you can contact.

Prioritize placements you can trace to a campaign that bought ranking credit. Investigate unfamiliar links by checking their context, timing and any relationship to your campaigns. Random mentions and scraped copies can turn up in reports. Use a risk score to order the review, then document the evidence for each decision.

Act on confirmed link problems

Pause orders tied to the pattern you found. Contact the publisher and request removal or, where there is a legitimate paid placement to keep, appropriate qualification. Track each request, reply and confirmed change. If a publisher reports that it removed a link, recheck the source page and record what you find.

If organic traffic has dropped, check the timing and affected pages before attributing the change to links. Review search impressions and clicks, technical changes, search demand and any reported action in the property. Google outlines a process for investigating search traffic drops.

When Search Console reports an unnatural-links manual action, open the issue and follow the steps for the affected property. Make a good-faith effort to remove links you can reach. Keep examples of what changed and what could not be resolved. Use the Manual actions report.

Reserve disavowal for cases that meet both of Google’s conditions. There must be a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing to the site. Those links must have caused a manual action or be likely to cause one. Try removal first and review the remaining scope carefully before using the disavow tool.

After addressing an existing manual action, request review in Search Console. Explain how the issue arose, which placements were removed or corrected, and what changed in your purchasing process. Watch for the review outcome and monitor search performance separately. Keep the link cleanup record available for future campaigns.

Give the cleanup an owner and a review date. Keep the first export and the latest observations so the owner can check which pages changed and which require follow-up. If you inherit a disavow file, review its scope against the evidence before submitting a replacement. Google treats a new upload as a replacement for the existing list on that property.

Set terms that keep editorial control with the publisher

Choose a resource that solves a real problem for the audience you want to reach. A repair business could share a maintenance checklist or a clear explanation of when equipment needs professional attention. Identify where customers and trade editors look for that information through market research.

Give editors a reason to include the material and let them decide whether it fits. A campaign can focus on original guidance, a useful comparison or an expert contribution where the publication controls the wording and the link. Look for similar approaches in white hat link building examples.

For outreach aimed at U.S. readers, use subject and audience fit to screen USA guest posting sites. Check the publisher’s public articles and confirm who approves a submission. If you commission promotion, record the terms and evaluate relevant referral visits, inquiries and placements readers can see.

Use the same standards for the next campaign. Set an approval step for proposed pages and ask for a record of every live placement. Include ownership, editorial review and reporting when deciding how to choose a link building service.